The article by Dinesh D'Souza "America the Beautiful: What We're Fighting For" is an article that has a good purpose,a good use of historical facts, a good thought process, but was written too early. This article does not bear a date, but I would presume it was before 2005 and the escalation of the Iraq War and the "Taliban Strikes Back". I agree with most of his arguments and points, but the ones that I don't agree with, are possibly the ones that matter most.
I support the "War on Terror". My uncle, who I am very close to, has served in Iraq and my cousin has been in Iraq 3 times and Afghanistan once. He was among those that invaded Iraq in 2003. After serving my LDS mission, I plan on joining the National Guard, if I am not accepted into the USMA at West Point. I would not be surprised if in 4-5 years I am deployed to either area.
I disagree with D'souza on the idea of "Liberal" Islam. I think that liberalizing any religion to better fit the masses is wrong. A religion is not a popularity contest and it shouldn't be one. While all religions I think as religions teach the same basic principles, honesty, hard work, sacrifice, charity, and supporting your neighbor, there are some branches of each that find grey areas they use to advance violent programs. "Liberalizing" is the same as secularizing in my opinion. A religion should either stand up or sit down.
Also, I belive that the determination of the American people to fight this war to its end has failed. The American people no longer want to win, they want to withdraw and be left alone. Isolation has been popular in the past and is becoming so again. With the advent of a recession, they want energy, focus and resources centered here. We can not win this war, because we don't want to. We claim the cost is too great, the lives (both ours and theirs), the monetary cost is too great, and the time is too great. And we believe it. This war will never be won, because we don't want to win and because we won't finish it, it will go on forever.